Cervical dysplasia (abnormal Pap smears)
Cervical dysplasia (CD) is a precancerous lesion; risk factors similar to cervical cancer; lifestyle and nutritional factors in aetiology of cervical carcinoma; early age of first intercourse, multiple sexual partners, herpes simplex type II and papilloma viruses, lower socioeconomic class, smoking, oral contraceptive use, and many nutritional factors; all risk factors are closely related.
Abnormal Papanicolaou smear (stages II-IV); positive Schiller test.
*************************************************************************************
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Classification
systems for Papanicolaou smears
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Numerical Dysplasia
CIN Bethesda
_____________________________________________________________________________________
I
Benign Benign Normal
II Benign with Benign with Normal inflammation
III Mild
dysplasia CIN I Low-grade SIL
III Moderate dysplasia CIN II Low-grade
SIL
III Severe dysplasia CIN III High-grade SIL
IV Carcinoma in situ CIN
III High-grade SIL
V Invasive cancer Invasive cancer Invasive cancer
(CIN (cervical intraepithelial neoplasia); SIL (squamous epithelial lesion))
*************************************************************************************
• Epidemiology: Cervical cancer is the second most common malignancy in women aged 15-34 (can occur at any age); peak incidence of invasive lesions is age 45; in situ lesions peak age 30; invasive carcinoma rate is falling; incidence of carcinoma in situ increasing – increase in risk factors (early age at first intercourse, multiple sexual partners, oral contraceptive use, cigarette smoking).
• Histology: 95%
of cervical cancers originate in squamocolumnar junction of cervical os; in adolescence, glandular epithelium covers much of exocervix;
as adolescence progresses columnar epithelium replaced by squamous cells; activity growing area susceptible to multiple insults and
carcinogenic substances – metaplastic nature of conversion process.
Risk factors
• Sexual activity: early age at first intercourse
and/or multiple sexual partners – suggests sexually transmissible agent; arginine-rich histone or protamine released by sperm during
degradation could be oncogenic agent.
• Viruses:
- Herpes
simplex type II (HSV-II): 23% of women with herpes have CD or cancer, but 2.6% of those without infection; HSV-II antibody titers
are much higher in women with CD or cancer than in controls; women with herpetic cervicitis have four to 16-fold increased risk of
cervical cancer/dysplasia.
- Human papillomavirus (HPV): agent in
condyloma acuminate (venereal warts); detected in cervical tissue of the majority of patients with CD.
• Smoking: smokers have
two to three times increased incidence compared with non-smokers (17 times in women aged 20-29) – depressed immunity, allowing sexually
transmitted agent to promote abnormal cellular development; induces vitamin C deficiency; vaginal or endometrial cells may concentrate
and secrete smoke carcinogens; unrecognized links between smoking and sexual behaviour.
• Oral contraceptives (OCs): long-term
use linked to increased risk of thromboembolism, gall bladder disease, MI, mental illness, hyperthyroidism, hypertension, and cervical
cancer; OCs potentiate adverse effects of smoking and diminish numerous nutrient levels – vitamin C, B6, and B12, folate, riboflavin,
and zinc.
Therapeutic considerations
Nutrition
Large proportion (67%) of patients with cervical cancer have
abnormal anthropometric or biochemical parameters – height-to-weight ratios, triceps skin fold thickness, mid-arm muscle circumference,
serum albumin levels, total iron-binding capacity, haemoglobin levels, creatinine height index, prothrombin time, and lymphocyte count;
other patients marginal but ‘normal’ nutritional status; multiple nutrient deficiencies are the typical situation; at least one abnormal
vitamin level in 67% in patients, 38% have multiple abnormal parameters; nutrition plays major role in onset of CD/carcinoma; high-fat
intake linked to increased risk; diet rich in fruits and vegetables protects against carcinogenesis – fiber, beta-carotenes, and vitamin
C.
• Vitamin A and beta-carotene: minor association between dietary retinoids and CD risk; strong inverse correlation between beta-carotene intake and CD risk: only 6% of patients with untreated cervical cancer have < normal serum vitamin A; 38% have stage-related abnormal beta-carotene; low serum beta-carotene linked to three times increased risk for severe dysplasia; serum vitamin A and beta-carotene are much lower in CD patients than in controls; carotenes and retinols improve integrity and function of epithelial tissues, provide antioxidant properties, and enhance immune function; beta-carotene is more advantageous than retinoids – greater antioxidant properties, immune-enhancing effects and tendency to be concentrated in epithelial tissues.
• Vitamin C: diminished vitamin C intake and plasma
levels in CD patients; inadequate vitamin C intake is an independent risk factor for premalignant cervical disease and carcinoma in
situ; acts as an antioxidant, maintains normal epithelial integrity, improves wound healing, enhances immunity, and normal carcinogen
formation.
• Folic acid: cervical cytological abnormalities related to folate deficiency precede haematological abnormalities;
most common vitamin deficiency in the world, especially women who are pregnant or taking OCs; folate deficiency is the probable cause
of many abnormal cytological smears rather than ‘true’ dysplasia; OCs induce localized interference with folate metabolism – tissue
levels at end-organ targets (cervix) are deficient; RBC folate decreased (especially with CD), while serum levels are normal or increased;
OCs induce synthesis of macromolecule that inhibits folate uptake by cells; low RBC folate enhances effect of other CD risk factors
– HPV infection; low RBC folate is a risk factor for cervical HPV infection; folate supplements improve/normalise cytological smears
in CD patients; regression rates for untreated CD = 1.3% for mild and 0% for moderate; folate regression-to-normal rate reported 20%,
63.7%, and 100%; progression rate of untreated cd="16%" at 4 months; folate-supplemented rate= 0% (women remained on OCs); use vitamin
B12 with folate to avoid folate masking underlying B12 deficiency.
• Pyridoxine: vitamin B6 (RBC transaminase test) decreased
in one-third of CD patients; decreased B6 status affects metabolism of estrogens and tryptophan, and impairs immunity.
• Selenium: serum,
dietary, and soil selenium inversely correlated with all epithelial cancers and much lower in CD patients; one anti-carcinogenic effect
is increased glutathione peroxidase activity; toxic elements (lead, cadmium, mercury, gold) have selenium-antagonistic properties.
• Copper:zinc
ratio, zinc, retinol: increased serum copper:zinc ratio is a non-specific reaction to inflammation or malignancy; serum copper:zinc
ratio may be tool to establish extent of cancer; ratio > 1.95 indicated malignancy in 90% of patients studied; elevated ratios
also seen in OC use, pregnancy, acute and chronic infections, chronic liver disease, and inflammatory conditions; serum Cu:Zn ratio
should not be used to predict malignancy in these patients; decreased available zinc may cause retinol binding protein to be absent
or undetectable in 80% of dysplastic tissue vs. 23.5% or normal tissue – inverse relationship between serum retinol/zinc and incidence
of CD.
Miscellaneous considerations
• Vaginal depletion packs (vag pack): long history of efficacy for CD; mechanism of action
not yet elucidated; may promote sloughing superficial abnormal cervical cells; effective in most cases of CD.
Therapeutic approach
• Pap
class: class IV Pap – ascertain carcinoma in situ by gynaecologist; class III Pap – biopsy if patient has had recurrent abnormal Paps,
has significant risk factors, or has been unresponsive to therapy; carcinoma in situ or class V Pap – conization.
• Eliminate
all factors linked to CD (smoking and OCs); optimize patient’s nutritional status – supplement folic acid, beta-carotenes, and vitamin
C; vag pack will usually accelerate the rate of normalisation of cervix; treat patients who undergo conization for underlying causes
of CD; repeat Pap smears every 1-3 months, according to severity.
• Diet: decrease animal products – animal fats and exogenous
estrogens increase high-fiber foods.
• Supplements :
- folic acid
- pyridoxine
- vitamin
B12
- beta-carotene
- vitamin C
- vitamin E
- selenium
- zinc
• Vaginal depletion pack: weekly until Pap normalizes
(unless patient has had conization).
This article is to be used for information and guide line purpose. Any advice and/or suggestions from this article should be supervised by your health professional. ICIM can offer a medical professional at the centre to guide you through your health complaints. Contact ICIM for more information.
All rights reserved to ICIM Medics Ltd.
ICIM Medics, St. Johns Grove, Johnstown, Naas, Co. Kildare, Ireland.
Tel: 00353 (0)45 844 819 - www.icim.ie - info@icim.ie
designed by: Felipe Reitz & Ciara Fitzpatrick